‘Trump is obsessed with tariffs’


The last time we spoke to Paul Krugman was in July 2024. Months later, US President Donald Trump came to confirm that characteristic quote from the Nobel Prize-winning economist: “Trump is obsessed with tariffs.”

Kathimerini recently contacted Krugman again, this time to capture his first reactions to Trump’s “trade war” on China and the imposition of “reciprocal” – as Trump called them – tariffs. Speaking with clear concern, Krugman underlined that “we are experiencing the biggest ’trade shock’ in history,” while raising the alarm about the future of international trade in the “new era” of Trump.

Within a week, Trump triggered a trade war with the EU, later stalled it, and then announced 145% tariffs on China. What is the next day in his “new era”?

What is happening is crazy, and we are now talking about the biggest “trade shock” in history. You know, it is a huge increase in the average US tariff rate, which has never happened before, and now international trade is much bigger than it ever was. So, this is a huge shock, and it creates uncertainty. 

In addition, nobody knows what the tariffs will cause and what [Trump’s] next announcement will be. So, there is still a lot to happen on that front, and it is worth noting that international trade is just one of many areas where Trump is doing really radical things. We have radical cuts in government, employment, and huge changes in tax policy, and it is very hard to think where this will lead. So, the question is, how can people plan their lives and businesses in this environment?

How did Trump calculate the “reciprocal” tariffs?

It is crazy. The actual formula they used is: the bilateral trade imbalance divided by US imports, and then that is cut in half, and basically based on a claim that the result will eliminate bilateral deficits. However, in reality, it makes no sense and is just a formula that there is a dispute whether someone – basically uniformed – came up with it or they just asked ChatGPT to come up with a tariff formula. So, it is not a formula that any economist could come up with.

In your view, why is he gambling with a global recession?

He may not realize he is doing it. I mean, anyone who thinks there is a carefully calculated strategy here is probably just making stuff up. There is probably no such thing actually happening, and he is just following his instincts. You have to understand that he is surrounded by people who never tell him he is wrong. And it just so happens that the law in the US gives the president almost unilateral power to do whatever he wants about tariffs.

So, he does not have to get a bill through Congress. He can simply declare a state of emergency and impose tariffs as he wishes. And that has never been a problem in the past, because we have always believed that presidents would use that power sparingly. But since someone just wants to impose tariffs, he can just do it.

Trump’s adviser, Peter Navarro, has justified the tariffs as a way to bring manufacturing jobs back to the US. Is this feasible?

It is not completely impossible, or at least it could bring back some manufacturing jobs, although the tariffs probably will not do that. But, yes, the US has a trade deficit in manufactured goods, and we would have more manufacturing jobs if we did not have that trade deficit, but not a lot more. 

I have done some rough calculations that say if we eliminated the US trade deficit entirely, we could have 12.5% of the manufacturing workforce, up from the 10% we have now. But, you know, even if we had a 25 or 30 percent labor force in trade, we still could not get back to the kind of manufacturing economy we were. So it is mostly nonsense, it is not completely false, but it is mostly nonsense.

So, are we at the beginning of an economic “nuclear winter” as Bill Ackman predicted?

That is a bit of an exaggeration. Even those who really know a lot and have spent a lot of time studying international trade tend to think that tariffs are a little less important than those who have not studied it. However, the situation is very bad, and we have built an entire global economy around very extensive international trade. And a big part of that is not just trade in consumer goods, but trade in critical inputs for manufacturing, and all of a sudden, you throw acid into that system, and it is not going to work very well.

In a conversation you had with Ezra Klein, you stated that Europe will seek to export goods through Northern Ireland at a reduced tariff rate. Can and will Northern Ireland become a transit center for Europe?

I would imagine that if this starts to happen, then Trump’s people will try to crack down on it. What happens is that when you have very different tariffs in different countries, the possibility of transshipment as a way to get around tariffs is clearly there, but that requires, first of all, a whole corps of customs inspectors, which we do not have.

So, I imagine that if this scheme were to come into effect, there would immediately be massive attempts to avoid duties and then a frantic rush to try to crack down on [the bypass], which in itself would create huge backlogs at the ports.

Basically, we are in many ways in a kind of recreation of the supply chain crisis that happened after Covid-19. But, you know, it is not the Covid-19 virus; it is Trump’s brain that is going to create this.

Speaking of the long-term implications of Trump’s policy, we have seen Japan and South Korea in an unusual alliance with China for “free trade” and export control. Do you think Trump will lead the US to bundle Asian markets and isolate the US from the Pacific?

He is getting in that direction. Although remember, he is also doing a trade war against Canada and Mexico. So, it is like the United States is folding in on itself, and if we do that, it will be very ugly because it will increase the cost of all goods. In fact, it will make us manufacture much less competitively, and that seems to be the logical place he is heading for.

However, looking at the positive side for Europe, do you think that the European market will benefit from the import of even cheaper Asian products?

It is possible to happen while, among other things, the price of oil will fall due to the recession, and this will help Europe. However, we will have to wait and see what happens, whereas if Trump had not come in, Europe itself would probably impose tariffs on China because China has a large trade surplus, and most trade surpluses out there are warranted by the underlying economy. So, I am not sure Europe will welcome cheap imports from China; there may be a reaction, but it remains to be seen what the outcome will be.

It is worth noting that everyone needs to think about how to organize their international trade around the fact that the United States is no longer a reliable actor and that [the US] has become a “rogue” player in the world system.

What Trump called “Liberation Day” for you was “the biggest trade shock in history.” Realistically speaking, which school of thought will prevail and why? 

I am not sure there is a school of thought here. I mean, if you are trying to understand what the economic theory is that underlies what is going on, there is no theory. This is all gut instincts of an “imperial president” who, partly because of the way US politics has evolved and partly because of the way our laws are written, has almost unlimited power to do whatever he wants. So, what will happen two or three years from now as people look around at the “smoking wreckage,” I do not really know, but this is not a conflict between economic schools of thought, but a conflict between the president’s instincts and reality.





Source link