David Hill Sees Historic Opportunity for Return of Parthenon Sculptures


Former ABC managing director David Hill believes the return of the Parthenon Sculptures to Greece could mark a historic turning point for the global movement to repatriate cultural treasures.

Speaking with journalist Peter FitzSimons in an interview published by The Sydney Morning Herald, Hill said a decision by newly elected British Prime Minister Andy Burnham to return the sculptures would have implications far beyond Greece.

“If Andy Burnham has his way, and the Parthenon Sculptures are returned to Greece, I think this is a game changer for all of us,” Hill said.

Three decades of campaigning

Hill said he has spent more than 30 years advocating for the return of the Parthenon Sculptures after becoming involved with a Greek-Australian campaign group in the 1990s.

He later served as executive director of the British Committee for the Restitution of the Parthenon Sculptures while living in London, where he first met Burnham, then a Labour staffer who publicly supported Greece’s claim.

According to Hill, Burnham has consistently backed the return of the sculptures throughout his political career, including supporting parliamentary efforts to amend the British Museum Act 1963, which restricts Britain’s major museums from permanently disposing of items in their collections.

A centuries-old dispute

The interview revisited the history of the sculptures, which were removed from the Parthenon in Athens by Lord Elgin in the early 19th century while Greece was under Ottoman rule.

Hill acknowledged that the British Museum maintains it acquired the sculptures legally after they were purchased from Elgin by the British government in 1816. However, he argued that the legal debate does not resolve the moral question surrounding their removal.

He also credited the late Greek actress and culture minister Melina Mercouri with transforming the international campaign during the 1980s by insisting they be known as the Parthenon Sculptures, rather than the “Elgin Marbles”, to emphasise their origin.

Burnham seen as a potential catalyst

Hill contrasted Burnham with former British Prime Minister Tony Blair, who had previously expressed sympathy for Greece’s case but ultimately took no action after entering office.

He said Burnham has maintained his position for decades and has repeatedly called for the sculptures to be returned “with no strings attached.”

Hill believes Burnham’s long-standing commitment makes him the strongest British prime minister to date for those seeking the marbles’ repatriation.

Implications beyond Greece

Hill argued that returning the Parthenon Sculptures could establish an important precedent for other countries seeking the return of culturally significant artefacts held overseas.

He pointed to Australia’s successful campaign to recover Indigenous ancestral remains from British institutions following changes introduced under the UK’s Human Tissue Act, after intervention by former Australian Prime Minister John Howard and the Blair government.

Hill suggested that a successful Greek campaign could also strengthen Australia’s efforts to recover significant Indigenous cultural objects, including the Gweagal Shield, which remains in the British Museum.

While no decision has been announced regarding the Parthenon Marbles, Hill said their return would represent more than the resolution of a long-running dispute between Greece and Britain.

“It would,” he argued, “change the conversation about cultural restitution around the world.”

(Source: Interview by Peter FitzSimons published in The Sydney Morning Herald.)



Source link