An unlivable city | eKathimerini.com


An unlivable city

A tourist holds an umbrella to protect from the sun at the Acropolis hill archaeological site, as a heatwave hits Athens, June 27, 2025. [Stelios Misinas/Reuters]

On a recent Monday there was an anti-war rally on Syntagma Square and a march to the American Embassy. The following day, there was an anti-NATO rally at Syntagma and an “anti-imperialist” march to the same embassy. There’s no need to mention the traffic woes from the blocked streets and transport problems from the closure of Syntagma metro station was closed for security reasons. On Wednesday, streets were jammed all around the Panathenaic Stadium (Kallimarmaro) for a packed concert organized by the Greek Communist Party. And then on Thursday, the Acropolis Rally caused the closure of major avenues in the city center. And all of this happened during a heatwave in the middle of a city that is not designed to cope with multiple simultaneous events and where the smallest intervention throws ordinary functions into disarray.

There are a lot of people, in the meantime, who do not rejoice when crucial parts of the city are turned into venues for venting political frustration or entertainment. These are the people who work, live, circulate in or commute through the city center, people whose demands of the city are those of a citizen, not a consumer. There’s a fundamental difference between the two: The consumer has the luxury to view the traffic jams, the closed streets, the suspended buses and metro services and the crush of the crowds as a necessary evil or even as something quite wonderful – at the end of the day, they will enjoy what they’re there for. The downtown worker or resident, however, has much simpler demands from the city: They don’t want it to make them suffer.

The argument in favor of antisocial behavior is as stereotypical as the antisocial behavior itself: It does not justify the few usurping the city at the expense of the many, but accuses the latter of being whiners, misers and snobs, brushing off their complaints with: “This is what happens in cities nowadays.”

That’s not true: In big modern cities, anything that upsets their operation is considered a problem, not dismissed as something normal. That is not to say that European cities we tend to admire don’t have their fair share of problems; of course they do, but they are treated as such; they aren’t disguised as good things so people forget that they are problems.

A modern metropolis is focused first and foremost on being functional and meeting the basic needs of its residents; anything beyond that comes second. That said, it doesn’t take great insight or sophistication to understand the obvious: When one road closes, another one needs to be opened; when one public transportation option stops, commuters must be offered an alternative; when a city becomes a stage of dramatized passions (political, cultural or sports-related) those who have no part in the drama need to somehow be protected from it.

Given all this, it seems hypocritical (or incredibly naive) to lament the “decline” of Athens, the impact of “gentrification,” the quality of life, the housing crisis etc. We can’t one day cry over the fact that residents are leaving the city center in droves and the very next day laud the actions that make life in it so unbearable that moving away becomes the only option. We can’t wonder why Athens’ population is not spread out across less popular neighborhoods away from the city center, when we all know that the further away you are from work, the more likely it is that you’ll be late getting there and back if it’s in the center or entails commuting through the center. It’s hypocritical to lambast private initiatives that “transform the city into a theme park” but turn a blind eye when the city becomes a playground for an activity that is to your liking.

The antidote to a city in a state of anarchy, one that both the state and private individuals treat in such a shortsighted and opportunistic manner, is not a dead city. It is a city that works, that lives by certain rules and that respects its residents’ right to some peace of mind.

And anyone who thinks that peace of mind is not a big deal has probably never enjoyed it.





Source link