Merkel: Referendum call in 2015 left her ‘speechless’


Almost 10 years to the day since the 2015 referendum in Greece, the woman who marked the era of the country’s debt crisis, former German chancellor Angela Merkel, was in Greece on Wednesday for a live discussion with Kathimerini Executive Editor Alexis Papachelas at the Stavros Niarchos Foundation Cultural Center in southern Athens.

In a candid conversation, Merkel talked about the discussions she had with former Greek prime ministers, the most “surprising” phone call of her political career, and her relationship with various world leaders.

Her visit to Athens comes just days ahead of the t10th anniversary of the 2015 bailout referendum on July 5. The former chancellor is reflecting on her personal journey, following the recent publication of the Greek translation of her book “Freedom.”

“Greece was freedom for me, I knew from history that it was the cradle of democracy,” she said, discussing her childhood, living in the German Democratic Republic and vacationing in Bulgaria. “I would climb the Pirin Mountains and from there I would see Greece and I would imagine how nice it would be to drink some Greek wine, and go further, to the sea.”

The Greek debt crisis

Merkel said she realized that Greece was facing a major problem “quite late,” in late 2009, early 2010. Shortly after, she was told that “Greece needs money.” “I said I’m willing to help, but I can’t just give Greece money,” because of the no-bailout clause in the common currency, the euro.

She said a phone call she received by then Greek premier Alexis Tsipras informing her about his decision to hold a referendum for voters to decide whether to accept a bailout deal offered by international creditors “was the most surprising of my political career.”

She said she was “left speechless” when the leftist leader told her that he would be calling for a “No” vote in the poll, as it was clear that a negative vote would mean Greece exiting the euro.

“We said that we could not make a decision for a democratic country,” she added. Merkel said her first meeting with Tsipras, in Brussels, left her unimpressed. “Then we met in Berlin. I was in front of the Chancellery waiting for him, and instead of him coming, he went and saw some protesters behind the Chancellery. He listened to the ‘Internationale’ with them while I was waiting with my advisers and the photographers,” she recalled.

The SYRIZA leader later told her that one needs “to take care of one’s fans, too.”

She said the pair, even though ideologically opposed, “gradually came closer.”

“The art of politics is that you have two positions, and you know that they will never come together, so the art is to form a common position. It is important to listen to the other person, and I consider it important that Tsipras was honest; he did not try to mislead me.”

Merkel, who became Germany’s first female chancellor on November 22, 2005, recalled another proposal for a Greek referendum put forward by former premier George Papandreou in 2011. That idea was eventually scrapped, amid growing discontent within the then ruling party, PASOK. The move to withdraw that proposal was “the best possible decision,” Merkel said, adding that the European Union “would not have known how to deal with a Greek exit” from the eurozone.

She said it was her view that Greece needed to get back “on the right track,” and admitted that she often played the role of “bad cop” in negotiations. She was also aware of her “unpopularity” in Greece, but said, “We had to return to a balanced economy in Greece.”

“I had been intensively involved in the Greek case and that was good because many issues changed, the municipalities and communities, or the land registry. All of this may not have been pleasant, but the state had to have revenue from taxes. That’s how things are,” she said. And while she and her finance minister, Wolfgang Schaeuble, were in favor of a debt haircut, European Central Bank President Jean-Claude Trichet and French President Nicolas Sarkozy opposed it, as they feared a “loss of confidence in the euro.”

“I believed that we should relieve Greece of the burden, but the others also had good arguments. That’s why we went into a voluntary process. At the time, it was a risky process. They told me, ‘You’re crazy’ for insisting on the haircut.”

She also clarified that she never sought Greece’s exit from the eurozone, even though her stance led to tensions with her finance minister. “In 2011, I decided that we had to do everything in our power to keep Greece in the euro. We had tensions on this issue with Schaeuble, who wanted Greece out.”

Knowing that Schaeuble wanted a Grexit, she invited him to accompany her to Brussels for a key meeting on the crisis and called him every two hours to keep him informed of negotiations. “If Greece was not to stay in the eurozone, the Greek citizens should say so, not us,” the former German leader said.

‘In 2011, I decided that we had to do everything in our power to keep Greece in the euro. We had tensions on this issue with Schaeuble, who wanted Greece out’

The IMF question

Asked about the involvement of the International Monetary Fund in dealing with the Greek financial crisis in 2010, the former chancellor said she was in favor, as Europe had no experience in dealing with countries with similar problems.

“It wasn’t about providing political cover internally in my country. The question was whether Europe could manage on its own. The IMF had experience with countries that had similar problems. Europe did not,” Merkel said. “I studied physics, I know numbers. I knew that a few million wasn’t enough. As chancellor, I had to have the legal basis to support the [bailout] program in the German parliament. We were also worried about the banks; the situation was really difficult.”

She said she knew that the IMF is “tough and independent.” Greece had already asked for help from the IMF, a proposal that had been rejected.

The former German leader said that she was also aware of “irregularities” in the Greek economy from German companies in Greece. “There are no Greeks or Germans. There are hard workers and lazy people everywhere,” she said.

The US factor

Referring to former US president Barack Obama, she admitted to the pressure she received, to the point of “crying.”

“Obama didn’t know the legal framework and wanted us to ask the ECB to provide liquidity – something that was not institutionally possible,” she said. She recalled how the then ECB president, Mario Draghi, acted independently, “firing the bazooka with ‘whatever it takes.’”

She also recalled the dramatic meeting in Cannes in 2011, when she was reduced to tears, as Obama and Sarkozy were trying to convince her to increase German contributions to the eurozone’s “firewall” to fend off attacks by panicking bond traders.

“[Obama] wanted us to tell the ECB to give more liquidity. My advisers were telling me that I couldn’t do that, it wouldn’t even be accepted by the German courts, and I had told Obama that,” she explained. “At some point I started crying, I was under great pressure.”

‘Dramatic’ migrant crisis

Recalling the European migrant crisis of 2015, when more than 1 million refugees arrived in Europe, fleeing wars in Asia and the Middle East, she said the issue had become so “dramatic” in Greece and the European Union that it necessitated a deal being done with Turkey.

“I knew I had to do something about the refugee issue; I knew we had to talk to Europe’s neighbors. That’s why I was in favor of the agreement with Turkey on the refugee issue. The situation in Greece was dramatic. The illegal immigrants had to be returned. Turkey got money in return. Politics needs realism, I had to talk to [Turkish President Recep Tayyip] Erdogan and I don’t regret it,” she told the audience.

The former German leader said that unsuccessful asylum applicants must be deported, as do those who have broken the law or are involved in terrorism, adding however that many immigrants have success stories.

She also recalled tensions between Greece and Turkey, when Germany tried to mediate. “The discussions with Erdogan were difficult, as we didn’t always agree. I always tried to take advantage of small opportunities so that relations didn’t deteriorate,” she said.

Trump and Ukraine

Turning the discussion to current international affairs, Merkel described US President Donald Trump as “an attention-seeker” who yearns for the limelight, recalling how he did not shake her hand at a meeting in the Oval Office in March 2017 – but that he did so outside the room.

“I said, ‘Donald, I want to shake your hand,’ and he didn’t. He wanted to draw attention to himself. That’s what he wants, to distract attention and have everyone look at him,” Merkel said. “And you can see this in what he is doing with the tariffs. In the end, he has to deliver good results for the American people. He has to prove his abilities, at least in his own country.” She said the European Union must stand united and not be intimidated when Trump imposes more tariffs on the bloc, but should retaliate with tariffs of its own. “I’m not saying we should break off our relations with the US, but we must enter into negotiations.”

The former chancellor also said she supports an increase in defense spending for NATO. “It is also in our own interest, for our security,” she said.

Regarding Ukraine, she said that she supports its sovereignty and that she considers it right to move forward in negotiations. On the issue of defense and NATO, she emphasized that “increasing spending is in our interest.” At the same time, she supported the need for unity in Europe and support for the welfare state, while warning against uncontrolled debt creation.

Asked about her life away from the limelight, she said it is “right and fair” that others now bear the responsibility of making the big decisions. “I sorted out my thoughts by writing my book. Now I have free time, it is wonderful. I can go to the theater, meet friends.”

Merkel, who served for 16 years, is credited with raising Germany’s profile and influence, working to hold a fractious European Union together, and managing a string of crises.

merkel-referendum-call-in-2015-left-her-speechless0merkel-referendum-call-in-2015-left-her-speechless1
Merkel revealed little-known aspects of the tense negotiations between Greece and its creditors in summer 2015 to a packed house at the SNFCC. Her presentation was attended by key members of the political and economic establishment. [Nikolas Kominis]





Source link