With the knowledge and experience of Greece that stems from his many years of diplomatic service in Athens, initially in lower-ranking positions in the 1980s and 1990s, and, finally, as ambassador from October 2001 to December 2004, American diplomat Thomas Miller advises the new US ambassador in Athens “not to try to sell the MAGA [Make America Great Again] agenda” to the Greek people, but instead, to focus on the issues that truly concern the Greeks, to listen carefully and understand their concerns.
Miller, who will be in Greece in the coming days to participate in this year’s “Nisyros Dialogues” on “The Eastern Mediterranean in the Vortex of Geopolitical Changes” on July 3-6, notes that under the last few American governments – both Donald Trump’s and Joe Biden’s – relations with Greece have been and will continue to be good.
‘As far as Greek-Turkish relations are concerned, I still see the irritants there and I don’t see an immediate resolution to the issues in the Aegean or to Cyprus or anything else. I think that’s just going to be out there’
He talks about Turkey’s strategic role and the relationship between Trump and his Turkish counterpart Recep Tayyip Erdogan, while, concerning the conflicts between Israel and Iran and Russia and Ukraine, he places particular emphasis on the enormous changes taking place in the way military operations are now conducted, emphasizing that everyone, including the US, must adapt accordingly.
How do you see Greek-American relations evolving under the second Trump administration?
Things have gotten much better in recent years. The irritants that were there before, which I think were somewhat a function of the time, somewhat a function of people, are no longer there. I think that in the last administrations, of Biden and Trump, things have been pretty good, and I can see them continuing. There’s no longer this big hang-up about the US. I mean, there had been a problem in the US with Greece, and I think that the Greeks, particularly under [former prime minister Andreas] Papandreou had some real antipathy that didn’t have to be. And [now defunct terrorist group] November 17 didn’t help things. But all that stuff is in the past at this point.
What about the US-Turkey relationship, given all the latest developments in the area? Some people talk about a personal rapport between Trump and Erdogan.
That still remains to be seen. What we saw in Trump’s first term was that he likes strong men. And Erdogan would like to be seen as a major player. He has offered to help, be a broker, if you will, in the Ukraine conflict. I don’t necessarily see a role for him in what’s going on between Israel and Iran, but Turkey has been a key player in a lot of stuff. It’s in a very key geographic area. As far as Greek-Turkish relations are concerned, I still see the irritants there and I don’t see an immediate resolution to the issues in the Aegean or to Cyprus or anything else. I think that’s just going to be out there. I think that it’s a time to just handle all this stuff brilliantly. In terms of global developments, I do not see this as something that’s going to be on the front pages.
Moving to the Euro-Atlantic relationship, can it be repaired? Can it get back to where it was?
No. I don’t think you go back these days. I think that some real damage has been done. But I can see some good coming out of all the damage. And that is that the Europeans will have a much more independent defense posture, not be as reliant on us as they were in the past. And I think that’s good all around. We already see the Europeans pledging to spend a lot more on defense. That’s pledged – it hasn’t happened yet. If it happens that’s good for Europe and it’s good for you. Now, here’s the problem, as the devil is in the details: Everyone, including the US, is talking about upping their defense budgets. Sounds good on paper, but when you really get down to the operational details, Europe doesn’t have much of a defense industry, and frankly, the US defense industry for all its traditional weaponry is very robust, but what we’ve learned out of the Ukraine conflict and also Iran-Israel, is that the nature of warfare has changed significantly. And I question whether the West, and that includes the US, is moving quickly enough to keep up with this changing nature of warfare.
Not even the US is keeping up?
In the old warfare you built big ships, aircraft carriers, a lot of planes, and heavy armor. That’s not the way war is fought anymore. Now it’s drones, hypersonic missiles and that kind of stuff. And we see that in Ukraine and Iran. And frankly, my question is, if you might want to raise defense budgets, do you have the military industrial structure to absorb these raises? I think there’s a real question there. They have to adapt. You’ve got to get beneath the headlines and ask some fundamental questions. It’s not for me to question defense posture or anything else, and when it comes to Greece and it’s traditional issues with Turkey, maybe advanced aircraft and naval craft will still do the job. But with the conflicts we’ve seen recently, you’re really talking about a very, very significantly changed nature of war.
Given your past experience as ambassador to Greece, what advice you would offer to someone in this position, especially to someone who’s a political appointee, which is different than a career diplomat?
We’ve had George Tsunis for three years, and he did a pretty good job. So, I’m not going to kind of give you the traditional “only a career guy will do well.” A smart person can do well. And if I was going out to Greece and I didn’t have a lot of diplomatic experience, I would go – by the way, I have not been in touch with her at all, I have not been asked – I would listen carefully. I would not try to sell the MAGA agenda to the Greek people. The issues in Greece are very particular to Greeks. If you want to do a good job, listen, absorb and see where there are common points of interest.
One thing I’ve learned of my three tours in Greece – almost 10 years – is that Greeks want to be taken seriously. They want you to understand not only their issues, but their culture, what makes them tick, and I’m not saying, you know, that any American will get out there and immediately understand everything, but make a serious effort. If you make a serious effort and you don’t get everything, people will forgive you. If you don’t make an effort and all you want to talk about is the MAGA agenda, well, I’ll give you just one small example. One of the issues in the MAGA agenda is very anti-diversity. That doesn’t work in many places in the world, including Greece, which is a very open society, and it makes an effort to give opportunities to people of all kinds of backgrounds and diversities. I think that there has to be an understanding that this is a Greek society. America makes mistakes when it tries to force its ideas, force its ideology on other countries. That’s what I would do. Listen a lot, and try and make an attempt to understand what are the important agenda items for Greeks.
Let me close with Iran-Israel, the Ukraine war, and their impact on Greece given its geographic proximity.
Let’s talk about Israel first, because that’s the most immediate. The risk of that really getting out of control was pretty high. And I think it would have had an impact on the whole world. You’ve read about all the gloom scenarios. We get involved in the conflict, and Iran retaliates, blocking the Strait of Hormuz, attacking its neighbors, oil facilities, terrorism around the world; it could have gotten pretty ugly, attacks on US military facilities, maybe on US embassies. We now see a chance for a different outcome. It’s not what Netanyahu wants. He wants to see the total destruction of Iranian nuclear capability; no enrichment on Iranian soil, no missile capabilities, the list goes on and on and on. In any case, developments definitely have an impact on Greece in terms of oil prices in terms of shipping, in terms of a lot of stuff that’s important to Greece.
And Ukraine?
In a way that’s more more difficult to see an immediate solution to it. At this point Putin is not at all interested in anything other than all of his demands being satisfied. I think the Ukrainians are there for some kind of compromise, but it’s got to be something that allows them to say that their struggle was worth it. But I don’t see any indication they are close to giving in to Russia’s demands. What does that mean? That means it is conceivable that there might not be a settlement, that it might become like a Korea, where there was just an armistice, but never really a resolution. You just draw the lines where they are right now, Ukraine does not recognize Russian occupation of any of these areas. That’s possible.
Can Athens contribute in any way?
Is there a role for Greece in that? I think there’s enough parties in the middle post interlocutors that this is not a conflict that will end, if you can find the right interlocutor. Everywhere from the Vatican to Turkey to others who offer themselves as interlocutors – we have definitely tried – hasn’t worked as far. So I don’t see that there’s a direct role for Greece to end the conflict. If you needed a negotiating venue, and I think Athens or anywhere else in Greece would be fine. What I’d actually do if you’re ever really looking for a venue, I’d pick a nice island and isolate everyone from all the media and everything else, just like [former US diplomat Richard] Holbrooke did at Dayton.