“Up until the 1990s, 80-90% of the island’s population were farmers and livestock breeders. The coastal plots were just salty old scrubland – no one wanted them. Families would just give them away to people they had no use for or even wanted to ‘punish.’ Within 15 to 20 years, the social hierarchy completely shifted. The ‘punished’ gained power and are now reshaping our island. The fact that they build wherever they want, use excavators to tear rocks from the sea, rip everything apart – that’s a disgrace to Naxos. They gained influence, and we were pushed aside. They took our water, they complain that livestock and farming ‘disturb’ them, and now they’re trying to devalue farmland altogether. They do whatever they want.”
Nikolas Pittaras is Naxos’ most renowned livestock breeder and cheesemaker, the owner of the Aegean island’s largest –and award-winning – dairy operation. While his tone may seem harsh towards those who turned to tourism, it reflects the growing frustration among the island’s farmers and herders. As Naxos embraces rapid tourism-driven development, the survival of its traditional agricultural community is becoming increasingly precarious – worsened by water scarcity, a distorted subsidy system, and fierce competition from foreign markets.
“Farming is being abandoned. Costs have skyrocketed. Those who can, give up,” says Spyros Skarpos, a potato farmer from the village of Tripodes. He believes water availability is key to sustaining the island’s famed potato crop. “In Plaka and Livadi, the wells yield brackish water because there’s no rain to replenish the groundwater. Up here, we have to drill at great depths and that drives up the cost. And you just pray the motor doesn’t break down, because even the cable to lower it weighs 6.5 to 7 tons.” Skarpos is reluctant to name exact drilling depths – many farmers on the island report going beyond 500 or even 600 meters.


Declining rainfall and booming tourism have led to drinking water being prioritized over agricultural use. “The first year that we felt our island was becoming unlivable was in 2019,” says Mario Vazaios, an economist and executive director of Naxos Festival. “As soon as September came, the Hora [the island capital] ran out of water and the municipal authority claimed the farmers’ supply. The farmers revolted and halted the water transfer. In response, the mayor brought in riot police from Athens to chase farmers through the fields.”
The situation temporarily stabilized in 2020-21, during the coronavirus pandemic and the drop in tourist numbers. But the problem reemerged in 2022, with the only improvement being the addition of a desalination plant. Water prices soared, making it unaffordable for farmers in the villages to even grow small vegetable gardens – yet swimming pools continued to be filled without restriction.
The water dispute exposed a deeper issue for the first time: rapid tourism development is undermining the very livability of the island – a striking paradox for Naxos, which still relies heavily on its agricultural backbone.


‘A nuisance’
“If there’s water, production can survive,” says Skarpos. “But we need real infrastructure. If the much-discussed Tsikalario Dam is ever built, experts say the aquifers will start to refill. Still, we have a problem with the plain in Plaka. It used to be fully planted with potatoes – now, one field after another is being built over. A house goes up, cuts through the underground irrigation lines we’ve relied on for years and we’re forced to reroute them. Then the homeowners complain that the crops, the dust and the spraying are a nuisance.”
‘If Naxos’ primary sector becomes unsustainable, tourism will lose its authenticity – which is what truly sets the island apart from the rest of the Cyclades’
“This year was decent in terms of rainfall,” adds Pittaras, “but the streams were choked with fallen plane tree leaves, so the water could not flow. Meanwhile, wells are being drained just to fill swimming pools. They could at least give us treated water from the sewage plant to compensate for the water they’ve taken from us.”
The economic transformation under way on Naxos appears to be structural. Antonis Sergis and Angeliki Grazia are two winemakers who have spent the past few years trying to revive the island’s vineyards.
“This year, only one in three farmers planted potatoes compared to the past. With ongoing drought conditions, many are walking away from the sector,” says Sergis. “But there’s a key shift happening: there may be fewer producers, but they’re cultivating larger plots or raising more livestock. In the past, 100 sheep made you a shepherd. Now, no one considers it sustainable with fewer than 300 – you need economies of scale to make it work. It’s the same for vineyards; you need adequate land to be viable. At the same time, new technologies are being adopted and more educated farmers are entering the field. But the tension with tourism remains, because farmland isn’t protected. Anyone can build in agricultural areas – and then turn around and complain that the farmers are a nuisance.”


Divide
“Twenty-five or thirty years ago, the people of Naxos didn’t want tourism. They were so self-sufficient that the idea seemed inconceivable,” says Grazia. “Over time, that changed – especially in coastal areas – because the island’s tourism model became tied almost exclusively to the sea. Until the coronavirus pandemic, the growth was relatively steady. Then it exploded. Everyone jumped at the chance to cash in.”
Grazia’s observation is backed by Greek statistics agency ELSTAT data on building permits issued for Naxos: from 118 permits in 2020, the number climbed to 175 in 2023 and 173 in 2024 – 679 in total over the past five years. Most were concentrated in the Hora (120 permits from 2020 to 2024), as well as in the municipal units of Agios Arsenios – which includes Agios Prokopios, Agia Anna, and Stelida (121 permits); Sangri, including Kastraki and Alyko (113); and Vivlos, which includes Plaka (98). In other municipal units, the number of permits ranges from just 5 to 10.
The rapid tourism-driven development of the coastal zones is widening the divide between the shoreline and the rest of the island. Recently, the Naxos Festival, in collaboration with Panteion University in Athens, hosted a forum on sustainable development on the island.


“Naxos has areas that are overburdened and others that are virtually empty. The population in the mountainous regions is dwindling,” said architect Chrysostomos Kypritzis, president of the island’s engineering association. “As a result, the lowlands are facing overtourism and strained infrastructure, while the agricultural sector in the highlands is fading. We need to bridge the two. On one hand, local production must advance by taking steps toward standardization and securing support. On the other, construction in unzoned areas must be curbed, with demand redirected toward zones surrounding established settlements.”
“What do we see when we look in the mirror of our tourism model?” asks hotelier Alexandros Frantzeskos. “We’ve given in to a model of uneven development. If Naxos’ primary sector becomes unsustainable, tourism will lose its authenticity – which is what truly sets the island apart from the rest of the Cyclades.” Frantzeskos points to a long-standing lack of strategic vision: “Superficial prosperity clouds the judgment of local society.”
The municipality did not participate in the forum. Still, Mayor Dimitris Lianos acknowledges the disparities: “In winter, Agia Anna and Plaka are ghost towns,” he notes. Yet he believes tourism is modernizing the local economy in a way that ultimately benefits the island. “The primary sector generates added value, but it needs to be connected to tourism in order to survive,” he says. As for construction: “I don’t think it’s putting enough pressure on the island to warrant halting it. There’s still plenty of space, especially in the mountainous areas.”
What is Naxos lacking? “It’s missing a new generation of professionals – people with vision who can lead the island forward,” he concludes.


“There are many vested interests profiting from the real estate boom in Naxos. We shouldn’t wait until things reach a breaking point to take action,” says Grazia. “What’s already done can’t be undone. But there’s still time to choose a different path – starting with a ban on out-of-plan construction. The people who come here aren’t looking for luxury; they’re seeking an authentic way of life. The people of Naxos are deeply rooted in the land. The island retains a strong base of young residents, has a strong sense of community, and is slowly awakening to the need to support the primary sector and curb unchecked tourism expansion. Naxos’ greatest asset is its natural environment, and protecting it should be our only way forward.”
“We farmers don’t experience nature in theory – we live it, with our soul. We are part of it. That’s one reason we might deserve a little more love,” adds Pittaras. “Farming is a calling – it sustains society. This island won’t survive on subsidies but on our work in the fields. Our Naxos has its own soil, its own sun, its own wind. It produces something unique – if we care for it.”