
View of Saint Catherine’s Monastery, shown in 1990. [AP Photo]
A comprehensive agreement that would have ended a prolonged legal dispute over property rights at Egypt’s historic Saint Catherine’s Monastery in Sinai remains unsigned, leaving the ancient Orthodox Christian site’s future uncertain.
The draft agreement and settlement contract was finalized in late December following extensive negotiations between Major General Dr Khaled Moubarak Hussein Bakri, Governor of South Sinai, and Archbishop Damianos, the monastery’s legal representative under Presidential Decree 306 of 1974.
The proposed settlement addressed lawsuits filed since 2015 by the South Sinai Governorate challenging the monastery’s ownership of 71 disputed plots. A five-member expert committee appointed by the Ministry of Justice detailed boundaries and characteristics of the contested lands. The agreement’s preamble stated that the Court of Appeal ordered the merger of two appeals and, before deciding on their merits, ordered the appointment of a five-member committee of experts from the Ministry of Justice. Cases were postponed, before an unfavorable court decision was issued last Wednesday.
The agreement explicitly recognized the monastery’s ownership rights, stating that the parties agree that, according to the registration of Saint Catherine’s Monastery on the World Heritage List, the monastery, its buildings, its plots, churches and related buildings constitute property of the monastery belonging to the Greek Orthodox Doctrine. Central to the proposed settlement was acknowledgment of the site’s UNESCO World Heritage status, granted in 2002. The Egyptian state recognized the area’s historical significance and cultural heritage dating to the 4th century.
Under draft terms, the monastery would maintain autonomy in managing its internal, administrative and religious affairs without external interference. The abbot would oversee all activities while cooperating with Egypt’s Supreme Council of Antiquities for building conservation.
Environmental heritage received special attention, with provisions protecting ancient trees. The seventh article stated that the parties fully agree on their commitment to reconciliation, waiver and termination of the ongoing legal dispute between the South Sinai Governorate and the monastery.
The unsigned agreement was referenced during Egyptian President Abdel Fattah el-Sisi’s recent visit to Athens. Sources within the Sinaitic community suggest the signing delay was intentional, allowing the court decision to create new, unfavorable circumstances for the monastery. It houses one of the world’s oldest continuously operating libraries and invaluable religious manuscripts.