
From left: View of the exhibition of the four works of Christoforos Katsadiotis as well as the large painting (R) titled ‘My dynamism in sickness ends”’ (2013), by artist Tasos Mantzavinos.(2013).
Two bullies barged into the Greek National Gallery just a few weeks ago intent on destroying certain pieces of art they found “insulting.” Their actions were almost universally condemned. It was followed just last week by another two similar incidents.
The first was at an Athens bookstore, where a group of bullies tried to break up a discussion because the speakers had the audacity to express opinions the bullies disagreed with. How dare anyone think differently from them? Unconscionable! Doing so, they seem to believe, gives them every right to threaten and castigate, to stop these thoughts from being expressed at any cost. The very thought makes their blood boil.
The second incident was much more serious, because the bullies who disrupted an event organized by students at the Athens Law School were armed. As Kathimerini reported, they barged into the venue with their faces covered, wearing helmets and brandishing fire extinguishers and bats, and attacked the students, sending one to hospital.
I cannot stress enough how serious these incidents are, and especially the one at the law faculty of Athens University. In any country with a modicum of democracy such an incident would provoke a storm. The same would have happened in Greece too, but only if things were a bit different. Imagine an event at the Athens Law School organized by the youth faction of some left-wing party being disrupted by far-right attackers wearing hoods and masks and wielding bats. Need I go on?
The worst thing about all this is not the bullying itself, but the silence, the desensitization to such incidents, the evasive attitude toward them. With few exceptions, the academic community will carry on, cowed and silent. Greek society will be indifferent, because it has become so accustomed to such incidents that it tolerates them. And, of course, any discussion about addressing the problem will stall where it always stalls: with those who have something to gain from the existence of “assault squads” or those who are simply ideologically fixated. They will do whatever they can to ensure that violence and the threat of violence are never eradicated from the country’s universities.
Is exorcising violence from our universities easy? No, it is not, but it is not impossible either. All it takes is for Greece to adopt any model of a liberal democracy that we admire. I have no idea what the situation is like in Denmark, the Netherlands or Switzerland, but I’m pretty certain they’ve found ways to protect academic freedom and to prevent universities from turning into havens for common criminal activity.
Why we haven’t adopted some successful model, and why we allow such incidents to keep taking place at our universities comes down to the monumental cowardice of successive governments that effectively refuse to protect rights and freedoms. But not to ignore the elephant in the room, it is basically the result of a certain mentality in a significant part of the left, which has grown comfortable with the existence of these groups because they harass its opponents.
The left that came of age defending the Gulags, Ceausescu and Castro doesn’t see a problem when opposing voices are silenced. It isn’t bothered by intimidation; on the contrary, it almost instinctively justifies it morally by demonizing its opponents and shamelessly whitewashing the thugs.
For example, one of the speakers who was attacked last week claims to have “changed sides.” Is it wrong to change your mind? John Maynard Keynes didn’t think so. But people whose minds have become rusty from lack of exercise – with minds that snap, corroded by years of oxidation, like twigs between thumb and forefinger (to paraphrase Victor Hugo) – consider having a different opinion a crime. And if you once shared their “correct” views but changed your mind, that’s even worse than betrayal – it’s a “sin.” And as we know, for those whose minds still cling to the rusted, dogmatic shards of the inquisitor, sin must be punished, and harshly.
Aristides Hatzis is a professor of philosophy of law and theory of institutions at the University of Athens.