Going The Last Mile For The Parthenon Sculptures


Negotiations for Parthenon Sculptures See Progress, But Key Hurdles Remain

According to an article just published in the leading Greek newspaper Kathimerini, titled the “Last Mile for the Marbles “by K. P. Papadiochou and Sakis Ioannidis, the Greek Government and the British Museum have made substantial headway in discussions regarding the Parthenon Sculptures, with one source close to the negotiations indicating that 80% of the issues have been agreed upon. However, this unnamed individual also cautioned that the remaining 20% is proving difficult, and further progress, even by small increments, will be challenging.

IMG 4164 1

These revelations follow months of speculation as to whether a final agreement may be imminent or negotiations have come to an impasse.

According to the report, for the Parthenon Sculptures to be returned to the Acropolis Museum, potentially under a formula that is disguised as a “loan” but which has a permanent character, three primary obstacles, or “thorns,” need to be addressed:

Scope of Return

A key point of contention is the number of items to be returned from the British Museum. Athens aims to repatriate sculptural items that are essential for completing the unity of the Parthenon Sculptures. While artefacts not directly relevant to this unity, such as the Caryatid from the Erechtheion, might remain in the British Museum, Athens is pushing for the return of as many sculptures as possible from this secondary category. The Greek government would like to keep the list of potential returns “open,” ensuring the agreement does not permanently preclude the future return of antiquities not included in the initial return phase.

original 1
Reuniting the Sculptures (Illustration credit: The Atlantic/ Dimitris Kapantais / SOOC / Getty; In Pictures Ltd. / Corbis / Getty)

Timing of Implementation

There is a difference in preferred timelines for a potential agreement. The British side reportedly wants to ‘lock in’ an exchange where significant Greek exhibits would be hosted by the British Museum in multi-year periodic exhibitions as compensation for the Sculptures’ return, with these exhibitions being staged in due course. Conversely, Athens desires the immediate implementation of any agreed exchange to reunify the sculptures and restore the Parthenon monument’s unity, given the already protracted negotiations .

Legal Framework

Disagreement persists on the legal formula for the sculptures’ return, ensuring neither side violates its fundamental “red lines”. The British Museum is reportedly insistent on wording that indirectly refers to a “loan,” which would offer protection against potential legal claims.  It is understood that Athens will not accept an agreement that implies a transfer of the (disputed) ownership of the Parthenon Sculptures.

09d74772 1985 4301 a014 303f91372e66
Nicholas Cullinan (image credit: Times of London)

Despite these challenges, British Museum Director Nicholas Cullinan recently stated in the Times that “the plans are taking shape,” suggesting ongoing efforts, though the path to a final resolution may be longer than his comment might imply.

The British Museum’s planned major renovation of its Western Range, which includes the Duveen Gallery where the Sculptures are currently housed, is seen by many as an opportune moment for an agreement.

The Parthenon Project, an initiative established by the Greek-American philanthropist, John Lefas, advocating for the Sculptures’ reunification through a mutually beneficial (“win-win”) agreement, views the museum’s renovation as intrinsically linked to a redefinition of its identity.

2be6f40cd4a30e48577f07e6179d4f44 Parthenon Project 960x600 1
From left: The founder and financier of the Parthenon Project, John Lefas, the former British culture minister Lord Ed Vaizey, shadow culture minister Thangam Debbonaire, and campaign staff members Melina Antoniadis and John Watts during their visit to the Acropolis Hill in late September 2024 (image credit: Kathimerini)

Lord Ed Vaizey, a former British Minister of Culture and co-Chair of the Parthenon Project, remarked:

“The British Museum is trying to redefine its role and influence in the global cultural environment and now is the time for Great Britain and Greece to resolve this centuries-old dispute”.

He also referred to an upcoming seminar being organised by the Parthenon Project in London on June 11 under the title The Rethinking a United Kingdom-Greece cultural partnership within the British Museum’s “reimagination”: What next for the Parthenon Sculptures?

709f143641d35db3a5a7f624dd4449b08b6b7d97 1333x683 1
Lord Vaizey (image credit: The Art Newspaper)

The panel will feature Lord Vaizey; Baroness Debbonaire, Former Shadow Secretary of State for Culture, Media and Sport and Co-Chair of the Parthenon Project; Lord Frost, Former Cabinet Minister and Chief Negotiator for exiting the European Union; Sir Stephen Fry, the well-known actor, broadcaster and writer and staunch advocate for return; Mrs. Mareva Grabowski-Mitsotakis, Founder of Endeavor Greece and Director of Mare Studio, and Lord Parkinson, the Shadow Minister and Former Parliamentary Under Secretary of State at the Department for Culture, Media and Sport.

A similar presentation was held in Athens in late 2024 and attracted considerable attention for its forthright and practical discussion of the various ethical and legal issues in play.

part1 scaled 1920x1920 1
The Parthenon Project meets in Athens, September 2024

According to the organisers, the British Museum stands at a pivotal moment as it reimagines its identity and its influence on the global cultural landscape. Plans for the redesign of the Western Range will be unveiled in 2026, and discussions on the role of museums, international partnerships, and funding are helping to shape the museum’s future direction. This momentum raises questions on the future of the Parthenon Sculptures, and whether the museum will seize the opportunity of a cultural partnership between the UK and Greece.

The Parthenon Project’s “win-win” framework includes proposals such as creating a non-profit Anglo-Hellenic organisation to act as a liaison and secure sponsorship for the Duveen Gallery’s renovation and the redevelopment of the Greek National Archaeological Museum. They have also suggested renaming the Duveen Gallery the “Prince Philip Hellenic Gallery”. These ideas are considered valid, assuming the underlying museological approach to the collection is maintained.

featured image
Imaging the British Museum (image credit: Lina Ghotmeh Architecture)

The final architectural plans for the renovated halls, designed by French-Lebanese architect Lina Ghotmeh, are expected to be released next year. A significant concern for Athens is the future museological approach to be adopted if no agreement is reached, namely, whether the British Museum’s collection will continue to be displayed based on cultures in specific halls or if it will adopt a chronological-based form of exhibition and display.

It is hoped that by then an enlightened cultural partnership will have been finalised and implemented for the long overdue reunification of the Parthenon Sculptures in their proper context within proximity of the Sacred Rock of the Acropolis in Athens.

 

George Vardas is the Arts and Culture Editor and co-Vice President of the Australian Parthenon Association and co-founder of the Acropolis Research Group, organisations which campaign for the reunification of the Parthenon Sculptures and which support the endeavours of the Parthenon Project.

Tags:
Acropolis Research Group, Australian Parthenon Association, british museum, Duveen Gallery, John Lefas, Kathimerini newspaper, Last Mile, Lord Vaizey, Nicholas Cullinan, Parthenon Project, Parthenon sculptures, Stephen Fry



Source link