A bolt out of the blue on Mt Sinai


A bolt out of the blue on Mt Sinai

The report was stunning, that an Egyptian court had ruled that the Monastery of St Catherine’s on Mount Sinai, the oldest functioning Christian monastery, was to be taken over by the state, its property confiscated. Coinciding with Thursday’s sorrowful anniversary of the fall of Constantinople, this was enough to set off a firestorm in Greek politics, on websites and in social media. Archbishop Ieronymos of Greece expressed his “limitless sorrow” and “justified rage,” while the government appeared taken aback. The government spokesman said that the prime minister “stands by the commitment that he received in public and privately from the president of Egypt… for the maintenance of the Greek Orthodox nature of the monastery and he expects immediate signing of the relevant agreement as formulated between the parties.”

On May 7, in Athens, President Abdel Fattah el-Sisi had stressed at a joint news conference with Prime Minister Kyriakos Mitsotakis: “I will not allow the relationship with Greece to be jeopardized due to the malicious rumors circulating about St Catherine’s Monastery… I affirm the Egyptian state’s commitment to the eternal and intact contract between the monastery and the state.” Mitsotakis had thanked Sisi for his “personal interest” in the “protection of the monastery and its Greek Orthodox nature.”

What happened within the space of three weeks? Did the Egyptian government change position? Did the court take a decision that differed from the president’s will? Was the reportage on the case accurate? Is it possible that what Sisi said in Athens implied that the Egyptian government believes state control of the monastery will not violate the “eternal and intact contract” between the two? The Greek Foreign Ministry’s spokesperson noted that “the governments of Greece and Egypt worked together systematically for an agreement which will secure the sacred Greek Orthodox nature of the region. We are expecting to receive the decision that the Egyptian court issued yesterday.” Whatever comes next, it is clear that the lack of coordination between the two governments left room for great and justified concern about the future of the unique, living monument that is St Catherine’s Monastery on Mount Sinai.





Source link