
Prime Minister Kyriakos Mitsotakis (left) hugs Emmanouil Karalis, the first Greek pole vaulter to take the gold at a European Athletics Indoor Championship, during the presentation of Nikos Michalopoulos’ book on the 25-year-old star athlete’s life, ‘Otan Koitas apo Psila’ (When You Look from Above), in Athens, on May 6. [Dimitris Papamitsos/Prime Minister’s Office/Via AMNA]
Is overcoming adversity really a matter of choice? Something Kyriakos Mitsotakis said over the publication of “Otan Koitas apo Psila” (When You Look from Above), a book recounting pole vaulter Emmanouil Karalis’ arduous journey to the top of his sport, set off a debate among the pedants of language. “Behind Manolo’s smile, there is sorrow too. But his message is that there are two paths in life: living in the shadow of your fears or finding a way to overcome them,” said the prime minister, referring to the athlete by the familiar version of his name.
Is this to say that people who are subjected to racism, poverty and all manner of injustice every day are to blame for not finding a way out of their predicament? Is fear of ruthless reality a personal issue, something you can overcome simply by wanting it really badly? The debate the prime minister unwittingly sparked is, for many Greeks, an existential one that stems from the years of the economic crisis. Such glib pronouncements about what it takes to make good obviously struck a nerve: Do people working two jobs to make ends meet need to get a third if they hope to emerge from the shadow of fear? Should they take a stab at becoming entrepreneurs or life coaches? Things are a lot more complicated than that.
Is fear of ruthless reality a personal issue, something you can overcome simply by wanting it really badly?
The view of the world as a kind of dynamic stock market where all it takes to succeed is a few right moves and some discipline, is naive – and it is usually fostered by those who come from privilege anyway. Since those with privilege (great or small) tend to begin their journey equipped with advantages that serve as useful tools for advancement (financial, social or educational), they have trouble imagining that others may start with nothing, and often from environments that not only discourage progress but actively punish those who try to improve their circumstances.
Then there are the unpredictable factors: Not everyone, for example, has the same talent or luck. Some may have neither. So, the “shadow of fear” is not merely a subjective limitation to be cast off with the right mindset or behavior – it is a very real obstacle, and managing it does not depend solely on the individual. What can you do if you’re an aspiring athlete without access to proper training facilities? How can you defend yourself and reach your potential if you’re being bullied in a tight-knit community? Sure, even the most entrenched barriers can sometimes be overcome. But no one reaches their destination by choosing between resignation to fate or a heroic escape from it. Most lives are shaped somewhere in-between.
Anyone who goes to the trouble of looking at the world free from prejudice will realize that people are not entirely responsible for the things that happen to them. This does not mean they can’t turn their lives around, even with the meagerest of means. The way that those angered by Mitsotakis’ remarks seem to dismiss personal responsibility is just as stereotypical as the simplistic view of success expressed by the prime minister. Personal initiative and the willingness to overcome obstacles are not in opposition to the surrounding negativity; on the contrary, they are essential precisely because of it. Since conditions are rarely ideal, it is necessary to work against them with persistence. Because, for most people, things don’t simply fall into place, taking individual action is crucial. Statistically, there may not be many more stories like Karalis’ – but major victories aren’t limited to those on a grand scale. And while life itself may not be a choice, effort is. Anyone who believes that effort is a waste of time should try telling that to those who struggle every day against all odds – try telling them that their choices don’t matter, because the game is rigged.