
The wreckage of the trains lie on the rail lines, after the collision, the country’s deadliest on record, at Tempe, about 376 kilometers (235 miles) north of Athens, on February 28, 2023.The photo was taken on March 3. [AP]
The president of the Tempe victims’ relatives association, Maria Karystianou, has strongly criticized the findings of a new expert report that engine oils could have created the large explosion and fireball that followed the deadly train collision in February 2023.
In the report published Tuesday, Professor Dimitris Karonis, head of the Fuel and Lubricants Technology Laboratory of the National Technical University of Athens, suggested that silicone oils can ignite at temperatures of 330°C and above, under the conditions created by the accident.
Karystianou dismissed the conclusion as speculative and unfounded. In a social media post, she described the findings as a “miscarriage” of scientific analysis, arguing that the conditions described in the report were unrealistic in the context of a high-speed head-on train collision.
She also criticized the report’s reference to video evidence retrieved years later, suggesting it relied on questionable material to dismiss the possibility of illegal freight contributing to the fire.
Karystianou announced the association’s intent to send the report to the international scientific community, accusing Karonis of undermining the work of other experts with “hypothetical reports” that risk public misinformation.
The report’s findings were also publicly challenged by Course of Freedom leader Zoe Konstantopoulou MP. Speaking to reporters in Thessaloniki, Konstantopoulou said the conclusions attributed to Karonis “are in direct contradiction to the experiments he himself has conducted” and called on him to provide explanations.
“I am truly astonished that the government thinks society does not understand that manipulations, pressures, blackmail and extortion methods are rampant,” she said, suggesting the report may be part of broader efforts to obscure the truth about the tragedy. She also expressed concern over the 14-month delay in submitting the findings and warned that tampering with evidence constitutes a criminal offense.
Konstantopoulou reiterated her party’s support for the victims’ families, saying, “I am on the side of the families, who alone are fighting for the truth, against a system that is fighting them … We will win this fight for justice.”
Defending the report’s findings, government spokesperson Pavlos Marinakis accused the opposition of exploiting the tragedy for political gain. “Today puts an end to the most obscene effort to manipulate public opinion that I can remember … the narrative built by the opposition, en masse, upon a tragic accident,” he said. Marinakis emphasized that the report conclusively disproves the theory that the freight train was carrying illegal flammable cargo, a claim made repeatedly in political discourse since the accident.
He argued that earlier speculation, including references in the Hellenic Aviation and Railway Safety Investigation Agency (HARSIA) report to unknown fuel sources, had already been disputed by experts.
Marinakis singled out PASOK leader Nikos Androulakis for prematurely adopting this narrative, accusing him and other opposition figures of fueling a “cover-up” theory without waiting for official findings. “Tempe is a national tragedy … but the narrative of a cover-up and an illegal cargo has been resoundingly proved false and those that promoted it must first of all answer to society,” he added.
The head-on collision between a freight train and a passenger train on 28 February 2023 killed 57 mostly young people who had been returning to university after a public holiday.