The return to Greece of the controversial Elgin collection of Parthenon Sculptures, currently held in the British Museum, has in recent years been the subject of countless media reports and seemingly endless conjecture as to the prospects of resolving what is arguably the world’s most famous cultural heritage dispute.
However, recent developments in both Westminster, the seat of the British Parliament, and Bloomsbury, the home of the British Museum, have raised questions about how realistic the prospects are for an enlightened cultural partnership that would see all the known surviving sculptures in London and Athens eventually reunited in the New Acropolis Museum.
The British cultural establishment has constantly embraced the previous Tory government’s ‘retain and explain’ mantra in opposing restitution of cultural objects, including most notably the Benin Bronzes and the sensitive Magdala Treasures from Ethiopia, both seized at the barrel of British colonial guns, and the Gweagal Shield, a highly symbolic cultural artefact taken by a British naval force in its first encounter with the Australian indigenous peoples in 1770.

That colonial mindset is also entrenched in the case of the Parthenon Sculptures taken by Lord Elgin’s men from the Acropolis in Ottoman-occupied Athens at the beginning of the nineteenth century.

In November 2021 the Greek Prime Minister Kyriakos Mitsotakis famously went to Downing Street and spoke with his then counterpart, Boris Johnson (three UK Prime Ministers ago) about negotiating the restoration of the monument in its entirety at the Acropolis Museum, appealing to the British sense of fair play and justice. Mitsotakis underlined that the fate of the marbles was an important bilateral issue between the countries and that Greece would employ all means at its disposal to achieve this noble target.
Enter George Osborne, a former Tory Chancellor of the Exchequer and now Chair of Trustees of the British Museum. Osborne came out to say, in effect, that a deal could be done with the Greeks and it has been widely reported that high-level (albeit intermittent) negotiations have been held between the Greek Prime Minister’s Office and the British Museum since 2022.

But is a final deal within reach? Is there a proverbial Attic light at the end of this British Museum tunnel?
With the advent of the Sir Kier Starmer-led Labour Government in 2024, there was renewed optimism in some quarters. Unlike his Conservative predecessors, Starmer declared that his government would not stand in the way of any arrangement that may be reached whilst at the same time stressing that his government had no intention of amending the British Museum Act to allow for the de-accessioning of items within its collection.
This recalls what the author of this op-ed has labelled as a Cultural Catch 22: the British Museum insists that it cannot return objects within its collection because it is prohibited by its enabling legislation and the government of the day states that it is a matter solely for the British Museum but it has no plans to change that law.
In December 2024 Osborne admitted that the British Museum and the Greek government were “still some distance” from agreeing a deal on the future of the Parthenon sculptures.

In February 2025 the British Museum unveiled ambitious plans for the extensive and costly remodelling and refurbishment of the so-called Western Range of the British Museum, including the Duveen Gallery which currently houses the Parthenon Sculptures. The renderings prepared by the winning architectural firm depicted the new Greek galleries without the Parthenon Sculptures.
A gesture to cultural diplomacy or a case of simply playing it safe?

On 30 April of this year a motion was debated in the Westminster Room of the Parliament at the instigation of a Conservative MP, Alberto Costa, who sought to have a discussion about the Parthenon Marbles and the British Museum Act 1963. In his speech, Costa declared that there is an opportunity for the United Kingdom to materially benefit from some form of deal or agreement that goes beyond simply possessing the marbles in the British Museum and inquired:
“What sort of creative but dignified win-win scenario could be reached between the UK and Greece?”
The Conservative MP from South Leicestershire actually suggested a phased return of the marbles over 20-30 years, potentially as a temporary or permanent loan, with Greece lending some of its prized treasures to UK museums on a rotational basis.
Pointedly, he asked that if it is the UK Government’s view that the British Museum trustees do not have the authority, under current British law to temporarily lend the artefacts to the Acropolis Museum, what legal changes would be required to permit a temporary or permanent loan, with the British Museum trustees retaining legal ownership of the marbles.

The Minister for Creative Industries, Arts and Tourism, Sir Christopher Bryant, rose to his feet and delivered a clearly considered and potentially ominous response.
Bryant reaffirmed that the Parthenon Marbles are not owned by the UK Government but by the British Museum, which operates independently under the terms of the British Museum Act. He also reiterated that the Act allows for temporary loans of artefacts but prohibits indefinite or permanent loans, requiring trustees to guarantee the return of items under an open individual export license valid for up to three years. In his own words, “that puts paid under existing law to any idea of an indefinite or permanent loan”.
And for good measure the Minister stated that the Government has no intention to amend the law to enable permanent or indefinite loans of the marbles to Greece.
The Undersecretary of Culture also reminded the House that the Trustees of the British Museum have been given fiduciary responsibilities under the British Museum Act to which they must adhere. He added that if they do not, they will find themselves in court.
The response in Greece was somewhat muted.

Interestingly, it was only in November 2024 that Sir Chris Bryant met with Olga Kefalogianni in London when the Greek Tourism Minister raised Greece’s longstanding appeal for the return of the Parthenon Marbles, stressing that it involves the reintegration of essential elements of the Parthenon, a global cultural symbol. Bryant recognised the importance of the issue and noted the challenges posed by the British Museum’s legal constraints, but assured Kefalogianni that the matter would be given priority in future discussions between the nations’ leaders.
Then, on 4 May, the Sunday Times ran an article about the worrying loss of support which the Labour Government is experiencing, especially in the wake of the successes of the far-right, xenophobic Reform Party at the recent local elections. According to the Times’ political analyst, Tim Shipman, the British PM’s team “wants to abolish the Department for Culture, Media and Sport – splitting it between the business department, the education department and the Treasury – allowing them to fire Lisa Nandy, the Secretary of State”.

One possible reason is that since Tony Blair came to power in 1997 there has been a revolving door of no less than 18 culture secretaries, and such a move would be seen as demonstrating an intent to reform the bureaucracy in response to populist pressure.
Whatever the reason, the possible dismantling of the DCMS could derail – at least for the present – any meaningful discussions with the British Museum as the entire UK arts, museum and creative sectors would struggle to adapt.
And then on 11 May in a wide-ranging interview with the Director of the British Museum, Nicholas Cullinan in the Sunday Times – “Inside the British Museum: stolen treasures and a £1bn revamp” – the issue of the Parthenon Marbles was briefly raised but dealt with cautiously.

Cullinan initially expressed some optimism:
“Plans are taking shape. We’d love an innovative partnership with Greece where we would lend things and they would lend things back, and we can share knowledge and opportunity rather than debate ownership.”
But when asked whether he would return the marbles, the newly-appointed director was somewhat evasive:
“It would be more about a partnership that could build in trust and depth. They are talismanic objects of this museum. We are clear in the labelling that they are under debate. We don’t shy away from that, but we need to be balanced rather than inflammatory.”
Acknowledging that part of the Museum’s role is about cultural diplomacy, Cullinan stated that the future lies in collaboration but warned that it is not for the museum to change things “beyond recognition or foundational things” because they are the custodians of the collection for the next generation.
When the Times journalist enquired whether Cullinan felt a twinge of guilt about the museum retaining artefacts that once belonged to other cultures and countries, the British Museum Director replied:
“I could make lobbying to get the Act changed my sole focus but that seems mad, and it may not be the right thing. I’m keenly aware that whatever I do future generations will debate, so I feel more comfortable with loaning items. This collection has been formed over three centuries. It is the world’s greatest collection. I don’t see my job as undoing that.”

These comments are in rather stark contrast to an interview which Nicholas Cullinan gave to the BBC in July 2024 following his appointment. When asked whether lending could work as a model for the Parthenon sculptures, because it would be very difficult for any Greek government to have possession of them and then agree to give them back, Cullinan expressed the hope that a partnership of some form would be possible and that was “something definitely we want to take forward”.
When asked hypothetically how he would react if the new culture secretary suggested that a change of law might be required, Cullinan responded that it is “definitely a conversation to have and something to explore clearly”.
Whilst hope springs eternal, it is apparent that any deal in principle for the marbles may still be some time off, if at all, especially if it is to be couched in terms of a temporary loan and subject to the constraints imposed by the British Museum Act.
Only time will tell if Greece has to reconsider its position.
George Vardas is the Arts and Culture Editor of Greek City Times. He is also a cultural heritage consultant and a long-time advocate for the reunification of the Parthenon Sculptures.