Europe’s top human rights watchdog expresses concern about pushbacks


A senior official with Europe’s top human rights watchdog has expressed concern about allegations of “persisting practices” of pushbacks of migrants at Greece’s land and maritime borders, urging the government to adopt a “zero-tolerance approach” to such incidents.

Michael O’Flaherty, the Council of Europe’s Commissioner for Human Rights, also calls for an environment where civil society, media and human rights defenders protecting the rights of asylum seekers and migrants in Greece can carry out their work free and unhindered

In a ten-page memorandum to the Greek government, O’Flaherty said that on a visit to Greece in early February, he heard “from legal professionals as well as representatives of civil society organizations, national human rights structures and international organizations that summary returns to Türkiye continue to take place.”

He added that he also learned of “allegations of unnecessary or excessive use of force and of sexual violence by members of law enforcement forces in the context of such operations,” but provided no specific details in relation to those claims.

O’Flaherty, who also met with an array of ministers and officials during his visit, including then migration minister Nikolaos Panagiotopoulos, then shipping minister Christos Stylianides, and Deputy Foreign Minister Alexandra Papadopoulou, added that he “welcomes the readiness expressed by the Greek authorities to investigate allegations of misconduct by law enforcement forces at the borders.”

He called on the government to “adopt a zero-tolerance approach to summary returns, ill-treatment, arbitrary detention and other serious human rights violations” and to ensure that “abuses are promptly, impartially, thoroughly and effectively investigated.”

However, the commissioner said that “the rare identification and punishment of those responsible for these violations, point to a persistent accountability gap,” noting that in the rare cases when the coast guard initiated internal investigations, they “systematically lead to findings clearing the relevant personnel of any responsibility.”

The government needs to “undertake a thorough review of existing accountability mechanisms competent for investigating and responding to human rights violations against refugees and migrants and take resolute action to address the systemic shortcomings affecting their effectiveness and independence,” he said.

Specifically referring to the deadly Pylos shipwreck of June 2023, in which “around 560” people are believed to have drowned, O’Flaherty said that the Greek Ombudsman’s investigation into the incident has faced a “lack of cooperation” that has generated “undue obstacles” to the inquiry.

The reaction by the Shipping Ministry to the Ombudsman’s inquiry was “unfortunate,” he added.

O’Flaherty called on the Greek authorities to “ensure that any responsibilities for any act or omission that may have contributed to the Pylos shipwreck are established … through prompt, independent, impartial, thorough and effective investigations and prosecutions, conducted with the adequate participation of victims and relatives, and able to lead to the identification and, if appropriate, punishment of those responsible, at all levels.”

Noting that nongovernmental organizations “operate in a challenging environment” in Greece due to a “negative rhetoric connoting NGOs as criminal organizations,” among others, O’Flaherty also called on authorities to “acknowledge the role and work of civil society and media and support human rights defenders protecting the rights of asylum seekers and migrants, including by creating an enabling environment where journalists, activists and other members of civil society can carry out their work free and unhindered.”

In its response to the commissioner’s memorandum, the Hellenic Police said it has prioritized the fostering of “a climate, mindset and culture of respect for human rights among their personnel, free from any form of racial, ethnic or other discrimination and in line with the Greek Constitution, as well as the national and international law.”

In its reply, the Ministry of Migration and Asylum said that a fundamental rights complaints mechanism has been in place since September 2023 that allows third-country nationals to submit standardized complaint forms. Of the 148 complaints received to date, mostly concerning reception conditions, 15 were found to be admissible and transferred to competent authorities for further examination, it said.

In his response, Stylianos Kostarellos, deputy prosecutor of the Supreme Court and competent prosecutor for monitoring migration cases, said “Greek prosecutors play a crucial role in ensuring effective accountability for human rights violations at borders. Under no circumstances do they proceed to dismiss the complaints without collecting crucial evidence, as stated in the aforementioned memorandum.”

“Where there are suspicions of breach of duty by the civil servants/employees of the country, mainly out of excessive zeal and with the scope to prevent members of terrorist organizations from entering European territory,” all such behaviors are reviewed by the competent authorities, he added.





Source link