A polyphonic view of our past


A polyphonic view of our past

Tourists enjoy the Acropolis view from Philopappou Hill, during the Easter holiday season in Athens, Greece, April 16, 2025. [Louisa Gouliamaki/Reuters]

The mayor had adopted his most formal tone, concluding with his short speech: “For us, our history, the history of our municipality, is the most precious heritage we have.” My own question was somewhat more prosaic. I was in his office representing the Greek Contemporary Social History Archives (ASKI), where I worked at the time: “I’m glad – this makes our job easier. Where are the municipal archives?” The answer did not surprise me: “You know, we don’t have an archive.”

Every historian has a similar dialogue to recount with some variations only on the blunt answer: The archives “were burned by the occupiers,” “thrown away during a move,” “there are some papers in a closed warehouse somewhere.”

I do not want to exaggerate the suffering of historians – compared to that of other workers in Greece, they are negligible. Such dialogues, however, encapsulate a characteristic of Greek society: the discrepancy between a rhetoric that proclaims history a priceless treasure and the reality of minimal investment in it. A literal investment, because archives – for one – are expensive. But also a metaphorical one, because access to them can spark discussions that make us uncomfortable.

This is a contradiction that reveals a problematic relationship with the historical past itself. Its background is related to an ultimately conservative perception that is comfortable with platitudes about the people not learning from their mistakes and other such familiar and trivial ideas. It is conservative because it arises from the concern that the disruption and revision of the past shakes up some kind of stability and, above all, the inherited tradition that history, the past, monuments belong to the sphere of the sacred and inviolable.

This perception runs through public discourse and appears at unpredictable moments: We recall the controversy over history textbooks, the intensity of the debate about the 1940s, the reactions surrounding the use of ancient monuments. And it may acquire new momentum through global developments. Very recently, US President Donald Trump’s White House issued an order for the “restoration of truth and reason in American history.” In it, he defines the content of museum exhibitions, rebukes institutions for promoting ideological schemes that “divide” American society, and proceeds to restore monuments in public spaces that are associated with the experiences of colonialism and slavery.

We should not be surprised if a similar ideological current makes its appearance in Greece, with the aim of marginalizing the very logic of a democratic and polyphonic view of the past in favor of a “true” and “logical” – whatever these concepts mean – narrative. That is, the institutional and top-down construction of a rule for the “correct” reading of the past.

Perhaps we should consider in this context the recent decision not to make the Acropolis hill available to award-winning Greek director Yorgos Lanthimos. The argument by the Central Archaeological Council that the scenes that would have been filmed there “are incompatible with the symbolism and values represented by the Acropolis” presupposes the acceptance of a logic that spaces have defined and stable values. And if one thinks about it, this somehow contradicts the very idea that the past – and its monuments – are by definition open fields to value, ideological and aesthetic readings. This is a starting victory of our democracy and our concern should be to deepen it. The past is not in danger from its open view. One could say the opposite. There it acquires productive dimensions, connects with contemporary discussions, leaves the sphere of the sacred and becomes an organic element of our lives and the revitalization of our societies. 

But all of this requires a break with the logic of the good mayor – and successive institutional links – who prefer to talk about the past through the prism of a legacy, rather than doing something about it through its socialization. 


Dr Kostis Karpozilos is a historian and a former director of the Greek Contemporary Social History Archives (ASKI).





Source link