Would we have Trump without social media? What role did new media play in the spread and prevalence of the MAGA movement? And how will they affect the new US administration’s opposition to traditional media?
Martin Gurri, a former CIA analyst, through his blog, “The Fifth Wave,” charts the evolution of the media landscape and believes that humanity is on the threshold of a new media age.
Speaking to Kathimerini, Gurri raises the issue of the “culture of censorship,” which is leading to the rise of reactionary individuals and politicians, and explains why Donald Trump chooses to communicate directly with his audience through unconventional communication platforms.
Opening our conversation with two notes from your book, “The Revolt of the Public,” I picked out the points that “revolts activated through digital platforms are mobilizing millions of citizens” and “The internet made it too easy to see the warts and corruption of politicians, leading to populist uprisings.” Why do citizens choose unfiltered and cheap information?
All information is filtered; otherwise, our brains would explode. The public has moved away from the traditional filters – old media – because it no longer trusts the content. With an almost infinite number of sources of information now available, the old newspapers and broadcasters appear limited in subject matter, condescending in tone, and, worst of all, boring. The public is interested in family, work, patriotism, sports.
The elites who control the media, on the other hand, are obsessed with climate change, immigration, multiculturalism, and transnational projects like the EU. The question we should be asking is not why the public has abandoned traditional media but whether traditional media will manage to survive at all.


On the one hand, we have President Trump’s constant postings on platforms like Truth Social, on the other hand we have his less frequent TV interviews on traditional media like CNN. Do you see an attempt to bypass the filters and control the messages he wants to send to the world?
Actually, Trump is on television far more than Joe Biden ever was – probably more than any president in history. He was once a reality TV star and understands the medium well. What Trump wishes to avoid is “mediation”: that is, journalists standing between his words and the voters. He knows the news media are extremely hostile to him and his positions, so his best political strategy is to speak directly to the public. Going digital with social media and podcasts is a way to bypass “mediation,” but the same is true of the sort of impromptu, free-form TV interviews he often engages in.
What is interesting about the new administration is that Trump has chosen “glamorous” and controversial figures, while technocrats have been sidelined. Is this an attempt to create a system of loyal followers with strong media representation?
Trump’s appointees differ from the typical Washington types in a number of respects. First, they are very young, with many of them in their 30s and 40s. Second, they are “rhetorical warriors” who know how to maneuver in the 21st-century information battleground. They post on social media and gravitate to podcasters like Joe Rogan, for example, and they treat the prestige news media with the disdain reserved for a political antagonist. Third, they are notably lacking in credentials – that is, in government experience. There is a reason for this. The people with experience belong to the elite class that Trump has vowed to overthrow. He tried to govern with them in his first term, and they almost invariably worked to undermine his goals.
The effect of the “new crowd” has been interesting. The city of Washington feels like it’s been occupied by a band of unruly young pirates. A chaotic energy pulsates through the usually sleepy processes of government. Radical change suddenly seems possible.
But governing entails knowing which levers to pull in the complex administrative machinery. Sooner rather than later, we will learn whether the “Trumpists” have the ability to accomplish this.
Do you see Trump’s approach to polarizing communication affecting the future strategies of other politicians? For example, could we see the radicalization of the Democratic Party?
Polarization is in the air, and has been for many years. Barack Obama was a polarizing figure – he suffered two severe midterm defeats and gave us Donald Trump as his “gift” to the world. Joe Biden was so polarizing that, in the end, he was rejected by his own party. All this is true in Europe as well. Emmanuel Macron is an extremely polarizing politician – it isn’t just about Marine Le Pen.
Conflict is polarizing, and the battle between the populists who represent much of the public and the elites who represent 20th-century institutional interests has been raging for two decades. Both sides have been radicalized. Trump often talks like he wants to change everything, including the air we breathe. But the same is true of the Democrats: Under Joe Biden, they aimed to change our sex, our vehicles, even the plastic straws with which we sip our smoothies, and they were willing to impose censorship, prosecute political opponents, and freeze disfavored persons out of the financial system to achieve their objectives.
In response to an article on populism in France, you noted on X that “populism is an effect, not a cause – not an ideology or a party. Populism is what happens when the elites fail on center stage.” In your view, where does the collapse of mainstream politics and the rise of argumentless political polarization lead?
Before we can answer that question, let’s first take a look at the world’s political landscape. If we do so without preconceptions, we will discover no trace of “progressive forces” or “mainstream politics” among the groups contending for power today.
The populists certainly are not progressive. Some, like Hungary’s Viktor Orban, are pursuing an expressly “illiberal” nationalist project. Others, like Italy’s Giorgia Meloni, are more interested in keeping out the tide of immigration. A third group, led by Trump and Argentina’s Javier Milei, wishes to reconfigure the structure of modern government. In their actions and attitudes, none of them resembles the 20th-century model of mainstream progressive liberalism.
But neither does the rule of the establishment elites. To an American, Europe’s digital censorship regime is halfway to China’s. In Germany and France, you can be arrested for mocking elected officials online. Populist parties are kept out of power arbitrarily. In Romania, the presidential election, about to be won by a populist, was canceled on the flimsy pretext that the Russians had manipulated TikTok. I would love to put Ursula von der Leyen in a time machine, so she can explain to John Stuart Mill how one must sometimes cancel elections to save liberal democracy.
So, your question really is: Will the current elite class survive? My answer would be: Probably not. Elites are inescapable, but the current group is singularly untalented and reactionary. My guess is that they will be replaced by a more technologically savvy crowd.
Recently, a Greek official reported that Russian-directed bots played a role in spreading fake news and mobilizing thousands of citizens in response to a railroad accident. Does social media serve as a powerful tool for foreign agencies to destabilize governments? Is there a specific methodology or tactic they use to manipulate public opinion?
Ask yourself: If you were exposed to falsehoods on TikTok or X, would you change your mind on any subject because of it? If the answer is “No,” then why do you believe your fellow citizens would change theirs? Is it because you are smarter, more educated, and more discerning than the masses? That is the Platonic guardian theory of government. It does not precisely coincide with liberalism or democracy.
Or consider: Vladimir Putin invaded Ukraine, and within 24 hours, he was the ultimate villain, and Ukraine’s Volodymyr Zelenskyy was a global hero. If the Russians are so cunning in manipulating opinion, why did not it happen the other way?
The internet is the mother of lies – but there’s absolutely zero data showing that any minds are changed, and there’s a lot of data pointing the other way. A battery of studies, for example, have demonstrated that “fake news” had no effect on Trump’s election in 2016. Other studies show that the human mind, once it has decided on an opinion, is extraordinarily difficult to change (see Hugo Mercier’s book, “Not Born Yesterday”). The natural reaction to false information isn’t to accept it – that would be an evolutionary disaster. It is to hunker down on one’s preconceived ideas about the world.
The Greek public already believed in the government’s incompetence or culpability with regard to the railroad accident. It didn’t need the Russians to mobilize. I would challenge your Greek official to produce evidence that minds were changed – from, say, “It was an accident” to “The government is to blame.” Absent such data, just pointing to Russian bots – like the supposed Russian TikTok manipulations in the Romanian election – is a mere pretext, not an explanation.
Propaganda can have some effect if the state has complete control over the information environment, but thankfully, in practice, that is an impossibility for democratic countries in the digital age.