‘We were rubber-stamping decisions, not forming strategy’


It has been two months since Spyros Artavanis-Tsakonas resigned from his position as president of the National Council for Research, Technology and Innovation (ESETEK) due to the “absence of a strategy on the part of the Ministry of Development.” He was followed by four more prominent scientists: Angelos Chaniotis, a Princeton professor of ancient history, Petros Koumoutsakos, chairman of the Department of Applied Mathematics at Harvard, Stelios Papadopoulos, co-founder and president of Exelixis Inc, and chairman of the board at Biogen Inc, and the rector of Panteion University, Christina Koulouri – among others.

Back then, the Harvard professor emeritus of cell biology had not wanted to speak in full about what led to his resignation or attempt an assessment of what was accomplished – and, above all, of what wasn’t. Now, from his office in Boston, he talks to Kathimerini about his term at the helm of ESETEK.

“The lack of a central body that can outline a scientific and research strategy and provide research funds based on merit continues to be a major obstacle to research, with the result that the valuable intellectual capital in our country remains stagnant,” he says. “Not only are we lagging behind in terms of research at an academic level, but we are moving in the direction of a weak and not rational development of innovation.”

“We tried with all our might. We created a council of particular scientific weight and scope, each of us has dozens, if not hundreds, of contacts in the international scientific community, but also in the business world. Unfortunately, all of this was not utilized as it should have been.”

Anger, disappointment, bitterness? What feeling prevails after your resignation?

I would say disappointment, because we did not manage to do what we expected to do. And, believe me, it is simple; the way the Greek system works and the indifference to research make it complicated and, ultimately, unfeasible. In theory, ESETEK, as “the highest advisory body of the state for the development of a national strategy for research, technology and the development of innovation,” advises on research strategy. Unfortunately, in practice, things were not like that. Our work was mainly bureaucratic and “fragmentary,” since we were not the only advisory body. Each of our proposals had to go through the minister, the deputy minister and the general secretariat and although most of the time there was no lack of goodwill, there was a lack of knowledge of what the practice of qualitative research is. Furthermore, essential issues were not reaching us or were arriving ready and pre-determined with a request for confirmation from our side. Basically, we were rubber-stamping decisions, that is, we were not forming a strategy. I would like to take this opportunity to point out that the government decisions regarding artificial intelligence were made without asking the opinion of ESETEK.

Was there any attempt on the part of the government to convince you to stay?

No, but I didn’t expect them to do so. This development was foregone because I had pointed out problems and dysfunctions many times, so my resignation did not come out of the blue. In 2020, when the prime minister proposed that I assume the presidency of ESETEK – and I responded positively, out of patriotism and a willingness to contribute – he had convinced me that he was willing to make radical moves that would change the landscape. Today, I think he has other issues, more serious for him and the government, that concern him and that research is not among his priorities.

You said from the beginning that the biggest problem today is the separation of research between the Ministries of Education and Development. Why do you think there is such a strong reaction to solving this problem?

Due to incompetence, if not stupidity. And because the majority of those in public office, from the lowest to the highest, have the mentality of not wanting to change anything. They tremble at the idea of change, stagnation favors them, they do not want to move forward, neither them nor the country. The fact that the necessity of placing research under the competence of the Ministry of Education was not understood, despite the many conversations they had with us, is tragic. With [former education and current finance minister] Kyriakos Pierrakakis we would have been able to communicate better, I am sure, as we did with Christos Dimas, while he remained in the Ministry of Development, as deputy minister of research and technology; he was the only one who listened and understood.

Do you have a comment on the resignation of Aristos Doxiadis, the former deputy minister responsible for research and innovation [over his past association with a company that went bankrupt leaving huge debts to the state for which he was acquitted and an alleged conflict of interest]?

I think Aristos paid for some of his social media posts about the Tempe train crash. That was the red flag, not the issue of the trial, in which he was acquitted. Too bad, because he was a good choice. Although he comes from a different field, not the scientific one, he is smart and logical. We worked together perfectly for more than four years. He also met the conditions to do something, for another reason: because the ruling party perceives him as their own man, close to their party.

During your tenure at ESETEK, were there any bright moments that made you take courage to believe that something can change?

We took some steps that I am pleased about, such as the evaluations of the 35 research institutes that exist in our country and cover many fields, from humanities to astrophysics. When I told the ministry that they would be undertaken by committees of eminent foreign scientists and Greeks from the diaspora, the answer was “That cannot be done.” But it was done. And they all did it without pay. Of course, after two years, nothing has been done to utilize the results of these evaluations. I hope they do not go to waste. Also, we appointed many electoral bodies with meritocracy and impartiality as our only criteria. We didn’t do favors or make any compromises on the quality and scientific weight of the electoral bodies and we fought hard for this.

Fought with whom?

With various centers – candidates, researchers, politicians – pushing for who should be on the electoral committees. A typical recent example was the unacceptable “campaign” aimed at removing from such a committee our proposed candidate, Joseph Sifakis, emeritus research director at the renowned Verimag Laboratory, perhaps the greatest Greek scientist in the field of computers and the only one to have been awarded the Turing award – the Nobel Prize in Computing – in 2007. What happened deeply offended him, resulting in him refusing to participate.

Was this effort of yours a waste of time, then? All for nothing?

To a certain extent, yes. On the one hand, we raised the standards somewhat, we prevented several incompetent people from advancing, but on the other hand, we were unable, due to the circumstances, to highlight those worthy and give them a boost.

Why is it so difficult to conduct basic research in Greece, after all?

When those who govern and decide are ignorant, what do you expect? A lack of meritocracy reigns. That is why we are and will continue to lag behind. Then, there is the absence of the appropriate ecosystem, of a supportive framework. New positions in research institutes have not opened for a decade; a technician leaves due to retirement and is not replaced. The salaries are negligible. There is no money for supplies: How can you do research without pipettes or centrifuge tubes? We are only interested in and boast about tourism. While countries like Portugal, Finland, Belgium, and the Netherlands support and promote research in cutting-edge technologies, which is the mother of innovation, we see our country only as a tourist product and are destroying it without doing anything for the future.

Through ESETEK, what idea did you form of the Greek state?

That it is terrible. There are few heroic employees who work with dedication and devotion and a rigid and exhausting bureaucracy. All efforts stumble at some point in the legislation. “The law does not provide for it” is the constant refrain for doing nothing. There is no common sense or flexibility. Instead of simplifying things, they are becoming increasingly complicated. The existing regulations, laws and provisions translate into particularly time-consuming procedures that leave no room for research to be conducted at the level it should. The most painful problem, which has enormous consequences, is the limits placed on universities and research centers by public accounting. If the Special Research Funds Account and research centers stopped being subject to it, most problems would be solved on the same day.

If you were 40 or 50 years old today, would you follow the calls of the “brain regain”? Would you return to Greece?

Absolutely not! And to be honest – and I say this with a lot of pain – I wouldn’t even advise a graduate student or postdoctoral researcher to do it. They will be buried scientifically. And besides, how will they support their families?

A few years ago you told Kathimerini that it’s the “deadbeats” who rise to the top in Greece, not the capable. Do you regret this statement that was discussed quite a lot?

Yes, I regret it. I should have said “complete deadbeats.” But I didn’t regret not receiving a single euro of public money. I even paid for my own coffee at the office.





Source link