Bread and circuses | eKathimerini.com


Bread and circuses

Replicas of sculptures are seen at the Parthenon temple atop the Ancient Acropolis archaeological site in Athens, Tuesday. [Reuters]

Our world has entered a new reality, one in which old alliances are being tested, friendships among nations strained, and well-established trade patterns challenged. It is also a time when institutions and traditions, however useful they might have been for generations, are being overturned. Democracy and the rule of law are being questioned; the political and international system established in the West after the Second World War might not last for too long. Political commentators and politicians are opining about these new phenomena, but I am an historian, my knowledge and expertise is about the past and I should confine my observations to yesteryears.

Every fall I teach an introductory class “History of Ancient Greece and Rome.” It is always well attended, and I try to make connections between the ancient era and our times. Sometimes I focus on architecture, how early US government buildings used ancient Greek and Roman as inspiration, other times I point to how ancient Greek literature and theater influenced the intellectual development of the West etc. In short, I am trying to teach my students that the ancients and their ways are relevant to this day.

When I teach this class again in September I will focus on three developments and examine what they say to us about our times. I will focus on two aspects of classical Athenian history and one of the late Republican Rome.

I will point to the Delain League; a volunteer alliance of Greek city-states created after the Persian Wars aiming to defend Greece from a possible new Persian attack. Athens was the leader of the League and for decades guided the rest of the many allies. But as time went by Athens became arrogant; instead of a leader of an alliance it became its hegemon. Athens changed from the alliance’s senior partner to a demanding bully. This arrogant behavior was damaging to the other members of the alliance but at the end of the day it was damaging to Athens as well. The democratic city that fought against the Persians as the shield of Greece came to be associated with bullying smaller city-states and its reputation has been, in part, tarnished forever.

I will also draw my students’ attention to the rise in democratic Athens of a new politician who appeared in the city during the Peloponnesian War. Cleon was a rich businessman, a newcomer to politics, who became popular as an anti-establishment politician. Taking advantage of Athenian discontent with the city’s democratic institutions, he gained power and advocated bellicose and risky policies. He was popular for a while, but his memory has faded and today he is remembered, if at all, as the prime example of a demagogue who governed badly and was interested only in his own glorification.

The last point I will make to my students will be about Roman history. How the Roman Republic started losing its way. How the Roman citizens lost interest in the Republic and allowed self-interested individuals to take control; and how one day old Rome disappeared. To be sure there was still a Senate, elected officials, and voting but a closer look revealed that all such processes were fake. The Senate had no real power; the elected officials were handpicked, and they went through the motions; policy was already set by one individual, Octavian/Augustus was the real unchecked leader. He held an office conferred to him by vote but there was no real choice; other magistrates were chosen by him before allowed to run for office. The Roman Senate was there to rubber-stamp decisions already made by him. The Roman people were encouraged to focus on bread and circuses and before they knew it they transformed from citizens to subjects.

That is all I am going to point out; there comes a time when a teacher should only point and allow his students to draw their own conclusions.


John Mazis is professor of history at Hamline University in Saint Paul, Minnesota.





Source link