“Messed Up” Australia Approves Trans Player in Women’s Football


The Australian Football League (AFL) has allowed transgender Adelaide footballer Freya Golding to compete in the local women’s competition triggering strong criticism, with international sporting and entertainment figures speaking out against the ruling.

Golding, who plays for Westminster Old Scholars, has received approval to continue playing in the Adelaide Footy League (AdFL) women’s competition.

The decision follows formal duty-of-care complaints from three clubs, which raised safety concerns over several incidents during the current season, including an alleged off-the-ball incident during Round 5.

Under the AFL’s guidelines, officials can individually assess a player if concerns arise that their participation could create an unacceptable risk to the player or other participants. Formal complaints can trigger a review by the AFL’s Gender Diversity Policy Committee, as happened in Golding’s case.

The committee ultimately ruled that it was not satisfied that Golding’s participation posed an unacceptable safety risk.

Golding, who reportedly stands around 6ft 2in (188cm) and weighs more than 90kg, previously played in the league’s men’s competition.

Different rules for community and elite competitions

Transgender women seeking to compete in the AFLW and state leagues must meet testosterone requirements. Community-level competitions, however, generally allow transgender women to compete in women’s competitions based on gender identity.

Golding has identified as female and has therefore been permitted to compete in the women’s competition.

The decision has generated criticism from prominent figures, including tennis great Martina Navratilova.

Martina Navratilova wrote on socials:  “Australia is really messed up when it comes to women’s rights.”

The Czech-American tennis legend wrote on social media that “Australia is really messed up when it comes to women’s rights.”

British actor and comedian John Cleese, best known for his work with Monty Python, also criticised the decision, describing it as “pure madness” on social media.

Stephanie Bastiaan, head of advocacy at Women’s Forum Australia, also criticised the ruling on X.

“Our position is that male-born players shouldn’t be in women’s sports full stop,” Bastiaan said.

Adelaide Footy League questions AFL review

Adelaide Footy League chief executive John Kernahan said he was disappointed by the committee’s decision.

“Our disappointment does not arise because the AFL reached a different conclusion than our own, it arises because we are no longer convinced the AFL was ever capable of reaching another one,” Kernahan told Code Sports.

Kernahan also criticised the AFL’s role in the review process.

“The AFL drafted the policy, the AFL promoted the policy, the AFL appointed the committee to oversee the policy, the AFL assessed the evidence of the policy, and ultimately the AFL delivered the verdict on the policy … in other words, the AFL marked its own homework,” he said.

The AFL had not responded to requests for comment at the time of publication.

Golding says they simply want to play football

Golding told 9News that they want to continue playing the sport they love.

“I’m not the biggest and tallest player going around and by no means am I a dominant player. I’ve had some good moments, but it’s rare I get in the best players,” Golding said.

“I just want to play the sport I love with a great group of people.”

AFL has faced transgender participation decisions before

The AFL has previously faced controversy over the eligibility of transgender players.

In 2017, the league blocked transgender footballer Hannah Mouncey from entering the AFLW draft after a five-person subcommittee concluded that her strength, stamina and physique gave her an unreasonable physical advantage over opponents.

Mouncey, who stood 190cm and weighed 100kg, had played eight matches and kicked 17 goals for Ainslie in the Canberra Women’s League before the AFL deemed her ineligible for the draft.

The ruling applied to the 2017 draft and the following AFLW season. Mouncey remained eligible to play for Ainslie in local football.

(Source. News.com.au)

Tags:
Adelaide Footy League, AFL, AFLW, Australian football, Freya Golding, gender diversity, John Cleese, Martina Navratilova, sports policy, transgender athletes, Women’s football, women’s sport

Kosta Papadopoulos

Kosta Papadopoulos is an editor at Greek City Times, covering Greek and international news, travel, sport, and entertainment.



Source link